Tuesday, February 22, 2011

LIT CIRCLES



I must admit up to this point my mind was beginning to spin thinking about all the state-appointed literature i must teach, the literature that may or not coincide appointed by the school board which i should teach, what i want to teach, and what the students really want to read. I enjoyed the concepts of letting the students chose their own literature and experiencing the "joy" some authors talked about of learning from my students about a book... however, like a hangover, reality hit me after the high. Do i really expect all my students to value and respect the freedom given to them to chose any book they want, and do i really trust myself to trust them to give me a true and insightful synopsis of a book i have never read? Plus i already know from this semester, even sometimes with this class alone (not to mention the other three lit courses i'm taking this semester) that i simply will not have the time to read all the books a completely free choice would place at my desk.
Now it was time to read Literature Circles: Voice and Choice in Book Clubs & Reading Groups...and my intial thoughts were," More Choices, More Reading?! HOW?!" Of couse by now you may have noticed that i am realistic and prepared (read "pesimistic and cynacle") and maybe even heard the thunderous noise of my eyes rolling as i opened the book. Though the flipside to my condition was realized again, as i was pleasantly surprized by this text. Harvey Daniels does a great job at constructing a book that is entertaining, quick to the point, stays on target, offers solutions, work sheet examples, and plenty to resourses to aid in implementing all you have just learned. i liked the balanced approach of student-lead, teacher-managed small groups. i found it releaving and insightful that he recommends beginning lit circles in the classroom for a portion of every class, then weening them to once a week, then fledging them to outside of class.. it's good for the students as they get to become comfortable with the new concept... it's good for the teacher as we get complete involvement from the students in the beginning, rather than just a flopped extra-curricular activity... and it's vital to the longevity of the lit circle itself. I also liked the concept of offering 4-6 selections for students to choose from, each ideally having some tie to the in-class assignment. I also appreciated the suggestion of having students list there top 3 choices to give the teacher the ability to keep small groups each with a book they want to read and also the ability to [ i won't use the t-word ] construct appropriately mingled groups of like-abilitied students so that the burden does not on one kid to support the group. I liked the idea of assigning different task-leaders within the groups and i very much appreciated the honesty and inclusion of failed ideas that are listed with this too.  And i will stop there so i can save some thoughhts for my presentation...
 The Book Thief- Kudos to anyone who finished this book already! I am certainly not there yet, but hope to be soon. I can say at this point, i find this book intregingly written- I mean, Death as the narrator! This book is also filled with humor, heartache, love, and nazis... if there happens to be a ten-story monster and a quality restaurant review later in the story i may never read another book again!

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

To Kill a Mockingbird and Houseon Mango Street

House on Mango Street, i unfortunately have to say was not initially gripping. Perhaps i will need to re-read it again over the summer to find what was to be appreciated in it. I get the the fact that it is to see the streets through the eyes of a young girl, who doesn't always understand all that is going on. i get that she is trying to convey the the trials and prejudices against the poor and the immigrants. i get that there is a sub-plot of her coming of age, and the sometimes exciting/sometimes frightening/ and often discouraging awareness of herself and her friends and cousins beginning puberty. but there is no plot, no conquering of an obstacle, no deep insight- unless you count that there are many names and images in clouds... i dunno, i don't think this book will be in my choice of curriculum, as of now.
To Kill a Mockingbird: I read this in high school. I mean, i was supposed to read this in high school. I am sure i read some of it, and probably took some notes in class; but i couldn't remember a lick of the story. Anyway, i was instantly drawn into this story. I am a slow reader and was trying to be aware of any details i could get as i read, so i lost a lot of sleep trying to get this book done in a week. Unlike Mango Street, this novel is a feast of plot, irony, cultural awareness, and coming of age. I am so smitten with the book, it's hard to write without gushing. I think Scout is just as relateable as Esperanza, i think they mirror each other in many ways... i think it is just a matter of the authors and Lee definitely takes the cake on this one. Diversity is expressed on so many levels, i think it gives a much more mature and honest interpretation of reality. There are several economic classes, though no one is especially wealthy. There are several social classes, based on lineage, though no one's family is truly older than anyoneelse's. Unlike the "black and white case" that Atticus was trying; this novel is about so much more than just black people and white folk.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Using Graphic Novels... and American Born Chinese

I thought this was a very good article, and certainly encouraging. The teachers observed not only the lack of willingness to read in the remedial students but took the time to notice those who read on their own time were reading graphic novels or drawing anime figures on their notebooks. They cleverly incorporated this into the class. though the media is nontraditional and lacks many formal techniques that most lit teachers are going to want to emphasize to their students, it was a great stepping stone to get the students involved in reading and to be excited about it. I thought it was especially clever to start outside-the-box by "reading" a graphic novel with NO text. This took away the mental stumbling-block the kids faced with their anxieties or disinterest in reading. It instead allowed them to focus on and develop a plot. Furthermore, they were then encouraged to implement their own telling of the tale and to eventually write a story using vocabulary discussed in class. There were two additional points i honed in on and hope to remember:
1. The "shades of meaning" chart as a vocabulary boosting and comprehension guide.
2. Having students share their ideas and progress with teachers verbally, rather than writing them. I never would have thought of this, though it seems so obvious; kids who do poorly at reading and writing are not going to do well when this is the only way of communication between instructor and student.
* i did also appreciate the sidebars incorporated into the article, like the "manga primer" and the list of graphic novels used.
American Born Chinese- What a book! I really enjoyed this book
 much more than i ever thought i would! First off, this was the first
graphic novel i ever read, and was honestly hesitant and doubting its
 merit. This book was easy to read and incredibly entertaining! That
 being said, it was also very clever and poignant; it stared in the face
 of discrimination and stereotype and was incredibly relateable. I
 think the tongue in cheek humor was smartly done and easy to
 interpret so that anyone who felt like a minority could appreciate,
 but it also dealt with such universal issues of acceptance,prejudice,
coming of age,defining of the self, love, and misunderstanding that
this could easily become apart of any curriculum.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

You Gotta Be the Book

Things i found interesting in this book thus far:
 *many teachers are unfamiliar with new literary criticisms
and New Criticism is still the most prevelant
*it is important to find a way to make reading a rewarding
experience, not just a way to find answers
 * p29- "'students must be free to deal with their reactions to the text,'
which also means that teachers should 'ask students what they see, feel, think
 and remember as they read, encouraging them to attend to their own
experience of the text'"
*when experiencing trouble with or refusal of reading- focus on the individuals-
not just the class
* i also really liked the idea of a teacher-student contract as noted on pg13